When Experience Stops Moving You Forward

The Momentum Files #78

Progress Requires a Different Approach

You can spend months analyzing a career decision or leadership problem and still be no closer to solving it.

Not because you haven't thought about it enough.

Because thinking isn't the same as making progress.

I've seen this throughout my years in corporate leadership and now in 16 years of coaching experienced professionals and executives.

Accomplished people are often very good at analyzing problems, evaluating options, and developing solutions. Those capabilities have helped them succeed.

But they can also become the very things that keep them stuck.

A leader keeps developing stronger recommendations when the real problem is a lack of stakeholder alignment.

An experienced professional keeps pursuing familiar career opportunities without questioning whether those roles are still what they want.

An executive keeps working harder to solve a problem that actually requires a different way of leading.

The problem isn't a lack of experience or effort. It's continuing to rely on an approach that is no longer producing the results you want.

And that's not something you can always solve by thinking harder.

At some point, you have to challenge your assumptions, engage with other people, try something different, and learn from what happens.

When Experience Stops Being Enough

Experience helps us recognize patterns, anticipate problems, and make decisions. But it also shapes our assumptions about what will work.

That's where accomplished professionals can get stuck.

They're not necessarily making poor decisions. They're applying familiar approaches to situations that may now require something different.

This is one of the assumptions I challenge in my coaching work.

When someone tells me they've been working hard to resolve a situation but aren't getting the results they want, I'm not automatically looking for ways they can do more.

I want to understand what they're doing, why they believe it's the right approach, and what they may not be seeing.

Because the answer may not be more effort, more preparation, or another round of analysis.

It may be an entirely different approach.


You Can't Solve Every Leadership Problem by Working Harder

Consider an executive navigating organizational politics, competing priorities, and difficult stakeholder relationships.

In recent conversations with experienced leaders, one executive described recognizing that working harder wasn't going to resolve these challenges.

That's an important realization.

I know from my years in corporate leadership that you can have a sound strategy, a well-developed recommendation, and a strong business case, yet still struggle to move an organization forward.

The problem isn't necessarily the quality of your thinking.

It may be that the people whose support you need have different priorities. That important conversations haven't happened. That others don't see the problem the same way you do.

Or that you're relying on your expertise to persuade people when what you really need is to understand their interests and build alignment.

One of the mistakes experienced leaders make is assuming that because their recommendation is sound, others should be ready to support it.

But people don't make decisions based solely on the quality of your analysis. They're considering their own priorities, responsibilities, risks, and the consequences for their teams.

If you haven't understood those factors, you may be trying to solve the wrong problem.

A better recommendation won't necessarily overcome a lack of stakeholder commitment.

And another round of individual analysis won't resolve an issue that requires engagement with other people.

This is where I challenge leaders to look beyond what they're personally doing.

  • Who needs to be involved?

  • Whose perspective haven't they considered?

  • What assumptions are they making about why others aren't responding?

  • What conversation would help them understand what's actually getting in the way?

The shift is from trying to produce a better answer independently to changing how they engage with the people who influence the outcome.

That's a different kind of leadership work.

And it often requires experienced leaders to move beyond the approaches that originally made them successful.

Growth Requires More Than Understanding the Problem

Another leader who shared a perspective with me wasn't focused on getting promoted.

The priority was becoming more effective in the current role, particularly in navigating complexity and creating alignment across different parts of the organization.

I think that's an important distinction.

We often associate professional growth with advancement, expanded responsibilities, or the next title.

But for an experienced leader, growth may mean becoming more effective at the level they're already operating.

It may mean learning to influence without direct authority, developing others' judgment, or getting better results through relationships rather than personal effort.

These changes require more than knowing what effective leadership looks like.

They require changing how you lead.

One respondent to my recent leadership survey expressed a desire to move beyond assessments, frameworks, and best practices toward measurable execution.

I understand that frustration.

Leadership frameworks can be valuable. I use them in my coaching work.

But understanding a framework doesn't mean you've changed your behavior.

You can understand the importance of delegation and still take back responsibility every time something goes wrong.

You can recognize the need for strategic influence and still spend most of your time focused on operational details.

You can know that a difficult conversation is necessary and continue postponing it.

Insight is important. But insight without application leaves the situation largely unchanged.

This is why I focus on what happens after a client recognizes something important.

  • What will they do differently?

  • What conversation needs to happen?

  • What assumption needs to be tested?

  • What will tell them whether the new approach is working?

The value of insight is what it allows you to change.

For another perspective on the role of coaching, see Why Professionals Hire an Executive Coach - In Their Own Words.

Sometimes You Have to Try Something to Learn What You Really Want

The same pattern appears when experienced professionals are considering a career transition.

One of the challenges I see is how easily people confuse what they're qualified to do with what they actually want to do next.

After years of building expertise and professional credibility, it can feel logical to keep pursuing opportunities that closely resemble previous roles.

But being qualified for a role isn't a sufficient reason to pursue it.

A recent Career Club conversation illustrated this particularly well.

A member was exploring opportunities aligned with a long-established professional career. The roles made sense based on experience, but the search wasn't generating much momentum or enthusiasm.

When the conversation turned to personal interests and projects outside traditional professional work, the energy changed.

There was curiosity and excitement that hadn't been present when discussing the job search.

That contrast was worth exploring.

Not because every personal interest should become a career, but because it raised a question about whether the familiar career path was still the right one.

After trying an activity that had seemed appealing, the member discovered that doing the work independently felt isolating.

That experience provided new information.

Perhaps the issue wasn't the activity itself, but the lack of collaboration and connection.

That opened up different possibilities for what a satisfying next chapter might involve.

That insight didn't come from more analysis. It came from trying something and discovering what mattered.

Meaningful exploration doesn't always provide an immediate answer.

But it can challenge assumptions, reveal priorities, and help someone make a more informed decision.

Two Questions That Can Change How You Move Forward

When someone has been wrestling with the same leadership challenge or career decision for weeks or months, I want to move the conversation beyond what they've already considered.

Two questions are particularly useful.

1. What have I been trying to figure out on my own that I might understand better by talking with someone else?

If you're struggling to build stakeholder alignment, you may need to understand priorities and concerns you haven't fully considered.

If you're frustrated with your team's performance, you may need to hear how team members experience the situation.

If you're considering a career change, you may need to talk with people who can help you understand what different kinds of work actually involve.

You cannot challenge an assumption you don't realize you're making.

Other perspectives can reveal what your own experience and thinking haven't.

2. What could I do differently that would give me new information about this situation?

This isn't about taking action simply to feel productive.

It's about deliberately testing your thinking against reality.

  • Have a different conversation with a stakeholder.

  • Delegate a decision you've continued to own.

  • Ask for feedback on how others experience your leadership.

  • Explore a project that allows you to test a possible professional direction.

  • Tell a trusted contact what kind of opportunity you're interested in pursuing now.

Then pay attention to what happens.

What did you learn?

What changed?

What do you need to adjust?

The goal isn't activity. It's progress informed by new information.

Breaking the Pattern

I've spent years on both sides of these challenges: as a corporate leader responsible for making decisions and delivering results, and as a coach helping experienced professionals and executives navigate their own.

Here's what I'm convinced of:

Your experience is an asset. But it cannot be the only lens through which you evaluate what's possible or decide what to do next.

When the approaches you've relied on stop producing results, the answer isn't necessarily to think harder or work harder.

It's to challenge what you believe, engage with people who see things differently, and test a new approach.

That's how you discover what your experience alone cannot tell you.

Meaningful progress doesn't come from understanding what needs to change. 

It comes from changing what you do.


Ready to Approach Your Situation Differently?

If you're facing a leadership challenge, career decision, or professional transition and keep coming back to the same questions, another round of thinking on your own may not be what you need.

I work with experienced professionals and executives who want more than advice. They want an objective thinking partner who will challenge assumptions, help them recognize what they're overlooking, and develop a strategy they can act on.

Let's have a conversation about what's happening, what needs to change, and how coaching could help you move forward.

Schedule your complimentary Pivotal Leadership Conversation



 
Next
Next

The Career Decision Most Professionals Answer Too Quickly